A $500 bonus bet is worth about $325 to $375 in cash once you convert it: bet it on an underdog around +200 to +400 and cover the other side with your own money, and you keep 65 to 75% of its face value whichever side wins. It is not worth $500, because a bonus bet never returns its stake, only its winnings.
In short
- Converted, a $500 bonus bet leaves about $325 to $375 in cash on either outcome.
- Unconverted at +300, it pays $1,500 about one time in four and nothing the other three.
- The cover at +300 needs about $1,151 of your own money for a moment; it comes back with the profit.
- The math is the same at every US sportsbook, because every one of them keeps the bonus bet's stake.
Let Promonyx do the math
Every sign-up offer in your state, the cover price found and both bets sized, one step at a time. Your first promo is free.
Pick your free promo →Why a $500 bonus bet is not worth $500
A bonus bet pays only its winnings. A $500 bonus bet that wins at +300 pays $1,500; the $500 stake is never paid back. If it loses you get nothing. That is why no sportsbook lets you withdraw a bonus bet, and why its cash value is always less than the number on it.
Converting it, also called free bet conversion, swaps that one-in-four shot for a fixed amount of cash. You bet the bonus on the underdog and bet the favourite with cash somewhere else, sized so both outcomes leave the same money.
What a $500 bonus bet converts to, at every price
The longer the odds you use the bonus at, the more of it you keep, but the more cash the cover needs. At +200 about $317.46 is left on both outcomes and the cover is $682.54. At +300 about $348.84 is left and the cover is $1,151.16.
Bonus bet at: +100
Cover at: -105
Cover stake: $256.10
Cash you keep: $243.90
Conversion: 49%
Bonus bet at: +200
Cover at: -215
Cover stake: $682.54
Cash you keep: $317.46
Conversion: 63%
Bonus bet at: +300
Cover at: -330
Cover stake: $1,151.16
Cash you keep: $348.84
Conversion: 70%
Bonus bet at: +400
Cover at: -450
Cover stake: $1,636.36
Cash you keep: $363.64
Conversion: 73%
Bonus bet at: +600
Cover at: -700
Cover stake: $2,625.00
Cash you keep: $375.00
Conversion: 75%
| Bonus bet at | Cover at | Cover stake | Cash you keep | Conversion |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| +100 | -105 | $256.10 | $243.90 | 49% |
| +200 | -215 | $682.54 | $317.46 | 63% |
| +300 | -330 | $1,151.16 | $348.84 | 70% |
| +400 | -450 | $1,636.36 | $363.64 | 73% |
| +600 | -700 | $2,625.00 | $375.00 | 75% |
Pick the odds your cash allows
If $1,151.16 is more than you want tied up, use the bonus nearer +200. You keep a little less and need a lot less cash.
Is your $500 offer really $500 of bonus bets?
Many "$500" sign-up offers are a deposit match or a no-sweat first bet rather than $500 of bonus bets in your account. Check which one you are being offered: a deposit match comes with a playthrough, and a no-sweat bet only refunds bonus bets if the first bet loses.
How to convert a $500 bonus bet
- 1Pick a game with only two outcomes, such as a moneyline that includes overtime.
- 2Put the bonus bet on the underdog, usually between +200 and +400.
- 3Find the best price on the favourite at an exchange or a different sportsbook. Never the same one.
- 4Size the cover: the bonus bet's possible winnings divided by the cover's decimal odds.
- 5Place the bonus bet, then the cover straight away, before the game starts.
Is it worth more if I just bet it?
On average, about the same: at fair prices, the long-run value of an unhedged bonus bet lands near the converted figure. The difference is the spread of results. Unhedged, most of the time a $500 bonus bet pays nothing. Converted, it pays about $325 to $375 every time. If you want the money, convert it.
Where Promonyx fits
Promonyx finds the sign-up offers in your state, finds the cover price across the exchanges, sizes both bets and walks you through each step. For the value of a real offer in your state today, see the state pages. Your first promo is free. 21+ only. Gambling involves risk.

What can go wrong?
- Prices move. If a price changes before both bets are placed, the number changes. Place the two bets close together.
- Terms. Miss a condition, such as minimum odds, a day of a run or an expiry date, and the bonus is not paid. Read the offer's own terms first.
- Account limits. Sportsbooks can limit accounts, usually after the sign-up offers. Betting both sides at the same sportsbook makes it more likely.
- Taxes. Winnings are taxable income (IRS Topic 419).
- It is still betting. One side is always your own money. 21+ only. If it stops feeling like arithmetic, call 1-800-GAMBLER.
Questions people ask
How much is a $500 bonus bet worth?
About $325 to $375 in cash once converted at odds between +200 and +400. In this page's example math, a $500 bonus bet at +300 covered at -330 leaves $348.84 on both outcomes.
Can I cash out a $500 bonus bet?
No. A bonus bet can only be wagered. Its winnings become withdrawable cash once the bet settles, which is why converting it is how you turn it into money.
How much cash do I need to convert a $500 bonus bet?
About $682.54 at +200 or $1,151.16 at +300, for the cover bet. That money comes back when the game settles, along with the profit.
What odds should I use a $500 bonus bet on?
Usually +200 to +400. Longer odds keep a little more of the bonus but need more cash for the cover.
Is a $500 bonus bet the same at every sportsbook?
The math is. Every US sportsbook keeps a bonus bet's stake, so the conversion works the same way everywhere. What changes is the expiry, the minimum odds and how the bonus is paid out, so read the offer's terms.
Let Promonyx do the math
Every step of the offer, the cover price found and both bets sized. Your first promo is free.
Pick your free promo →Keep reading
Sources
- IRS Topic 419, Gambling income and losses, checked November 17, 2026
- National Council on Problem Gambling, 1-800-GAMBLER, checked November 17, 2026
- Promonyx methodology: how example math is worked, checked November 17, 2026
How we checked this: figures are example math unless marked otherwise, worked on the date above, and offer terms are read on each app's own site. Our methodology. 21+ only. Gambling involves risk; if it stops feeling like arithmetic, call 1-800-GAMBLER.
